Meta in court: Will the subscription requirement now be overturned?
For months, Facebook and Instagram users have faced a choice: reveal their numbers or their data. But this “take it or leave it” approach could soon be history. The Federation of German Consumer Organizations (vzbv) is now taking legal action against Meta to stop the controversial practice.
Here’s what’s behind the lawsuit and what its chances are.
What exactly is this about?
Since November 2023, Meta has been presenting its users in the EU with a tough choice:
- Ad-free for a fee: Subscribe to a monthly plan (approx. €10 to €13).
- Free in exchange for data: Use the service for free, but agree to the comprehensive use of your data for personalized advertising.
The German Federation of Consumer Organizations (vzbv) has filed a lawsuit against this “pay-or-consent” model with the Higher Regional Court of Cologne.
The consumer advocates’ accusations
Consumer advocates consider the pressure Meta puts on its users to be illegal. The main points of criticism:
- Sham voluntariness: According to the GDPR, consent must be given voluntarily. Anyone who has to use the app (for social or professional reasons) and cannot or does not want to pay is forced to share their data, according to the German Federation of Consumer Organizations (vzbv).
- Misleading: For years, Facebook advertised its service as “free and always will be.” The fact that users now effectively have to pay with their data as currency to gain access contradicts this promise.
- Lack of Transparency: It remains unclear exactly how much data is collected when users agree to tracking.
The Core of the Problem: According to the plaintiffs, privacy should not be a luxury item that has to be bought. The right to data protection should not depend on one’s financial means.
What is a remedial action?
This is not a normal lawsuit, but the most powerful tool in German consumer protection. Should the vzbv win, the court can directly order Meta to cease the practice or pay compensation. Users would then no longer have to sue individually to assert their rights.
The goal is clear: The “subscription-or-data” model should be banned in its current form.
Conclusion: A landmark ruling
The outcome of this case will be groundbreaking for the entire internet in Europe. If the court overturns the model, many online platforms would have to change their strategies. However, patience is required until a final ruling is reached.
Beliebte Beiträge
Create annual calendar 2022 in Excel
In our tutorial we describe how you can create an annual calendar for 2022 with a display of the calendar week and public holidays in Excel, and use it anew every year.
Create individual charts in Excel
Charts are created quickly in Microsoft Excel. We explain how you can customize them, and also swap (transpose) the axes.
Create professional letter templates in Word
How to create a professional letter template with form fields in Microsoft Word, and only have to fill in text fields.
Create a digital signature in Outlook and Word
Create a digital signature in Microsoft Outlook and Word for more security.
Create a Table of Contents in Word
To create a dynamic table of contents in Microsoft Word - Office 365
Use bookmarks and cross-references in Word
How to use text markers to make your Word document dynamic and click through your pages.
Offers 2024: Word & Excel Templates
